Ponyville Easter Egg Star Song

This was part of the Easter egg set and I believe that it was exclusive to that set.

Release Date: 2007/2008
Value: $3 as-is, more like $5 with the egg.

Ponyville Easter Egg Rainbow Dash

This was part of the Easter egg set and I believe that it was exclusive to that set.

Release Date: 2007/2008
Value: $3 as-is, more like $5 with the egg.

Sweetie Belle Easter Egg Figure

This was part of the Easter egg set and I believe that it was exclusive to that set.

Release Date: 2007/2008
Value: $3 as-is, more like $5 with the egg.

Fashion Ponies Pinkie Pie

Release Date: 2011

Value: Stores are currently selling this for $15-20, but some online sellers want $25 or more. She's popped up loose for $5-10. If you have all of her accessories, the price is more towards $10.

My Little Pony Play Mat

 This play mat is adorable! It has a skid-proof backing that keeps it from sliding across the floor and its 24 inches long and a little over 16 inches wide. I saw some bad reviews complaining about the backing peeling off, but that only seems to happen if you use it continuously for a few months.

Release Date: 2011?

Value: Though it sells for $30-40 new, you won't get more than $5-10 used depending on condition.

Octavia T-Shirt

Release Date: 2012

Value: Another shirt from Hot Topic! It sells for less than $25 new and around $15 or less used.

Playful Ponies: Flitterheart

Release Date: 2011

Value: Flitterheart sells for around $5-10 depending on the store. Some sellers claim that she is rare, but she's readily available in my area. Loose, she might bring $3 or closer to $5 with her accessories.

My Little Pony Bubble Bath

Release Date:?

Value: A full bottle can run you around $3-5, and the topper itself can sell for $1.

Twilightlicious T-Shirt

Release Date: 2011-2012

Value: Hot Topic has these shirts for $25 or less, and you might resell one for around $15.

Playful Ponies: Rarity the Unicorn

Release Date: 2010-2011

Value: A few stores still have Rarity, and she only sells for $5-10 (more towards the $5 mark). I've seen her selling for $3 used, but you might pay more if she has her accessories.

Curad Kids Adhesive Bandages

Release Date: 2009?

Value: I've seen sellers asking $50+ for these, which is crazy. Even though the design changed, you shouldn't pay more than $5, maybe $10.

Derpy What Went Wrong Girls T-Shirt

Release Date: 2012

Value: This sells for $20-25 new, and maybe $5-15 used.

My Little Pony Sweetie Belle's Ice Cream Train Car

 

The  Sweetie Belle's Ice Cream Train Car works with the Express Train.

Release Date: 2011

Value: This one disappeared from stores around here pretty quick. While it only sold for around $15 new, it can go for $20 on the secondary market, and a loose set might go for $8-10.

My Little Pony Hypoallergenic Body Wash

Release Date: ?

Value: $5-10 brand new and maybe $1-3 for an empty bottle to a hardcore collector. You can unscrew the lid and reuse it with other types of soap or body wash.

Dress-up Daywear Bubble-Bath Time with Sweetsong

Sweetsong came with a few accessories for dressing her up for baths, though the curlers seem a little out of place.

Release Date: 205

Value: She originally sold for $6.99, and her price hasn't gone up much. I'd put her value at around $10-20 MIB and probably closer to $5 loose. If she has all of her accessories, she's worth a little more.

My Little Pony Fashion Ponies - Luna

This is the same pony available in a 2-pack from Target, which was an exclusive set. Some stores got Luna by herself.


Release Date: 2011

Value: Since it's still available in most stores, it's only worth about $15 (someone should tell the sellers asking $25+). You can find her loose for around $10.

My Little Pony Mouse Pad

Unless someone can prove otherwise, I'm putting this in the fakie category.

Release Date:?

Value: Less than $10 new or used.

My Little Pony Peel and Stick Wall Stickers

Release Date:?

Value: You will pay around $20 for a new set. I haven't yet seen used sets for sale because the stickiness fades after a few uses.

My Little Pony Magical Pony Express Train Set (Friendship Express)

 It comes with a Pinkie Pie figure, train engine, tracks, and a few other accessories.

Release Date: 2011

Value: Since it's still available in most stores, it's only worth about $20-30 new. I've seen people the loose pieces at $10 for the track, $3 for PP, and $5 for the train.

Computer Game: Pinkie Pies Party Parade

Release Date: 2007

Value: You can get it brand new for around $10-15, though MSRP is $20. Used, you should find it for less than $10.

My Little Pony Ponyville Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie and Scootaloo Figures

Release Date: 2010

Value: Some of these figures turned up in other playsets and packs. You can still find these in some stores for around $10. Loose, I would say maybe $3 per pony at the top end. I just bought Scootaloo loose for $1.

My Little Pony 42" Ceiling Fan

I was almost certain that this was a fakie until I found it on some big sites like Sears. If you already have a fan, you can buy the blades separately.

Release Date:?
Value: G1 pony stuff is hot right now, and the fan sells for $80-130 new. If you have one for resell, I'd put the price around $50-75.

Wall Mural Stickers

The cheapness of these stickers makes me think these are fakes. The "ponies" look a little too chunky and fakie-like.

Release Date:?
Value: N/A

So Soft Newborn Sweetie Belle

Oddly enough, the So Soft Newborn Sweetie Belle is getting hard to find. I keep coming across Pinkie Pie, but this one isn't in stores around here.

Release Date: 2010-2011
Value: Since it's still available in some stores, it's only worth about $20-25 for a NIB set. Loose, maybe $10.

Wysteria Keychain

Release Date: 2010?

Value: These were readily available in stores a few years ago and harder to find now. It's still only worth $10-15 MIP, thought some sellers ask $30+. You can make her legs move, and some of these broke down from kids playing with them.

Water Wow Doodle Book with Magic Brush

Release Date: 2010-2011

Value: $10-15 NIB, $5-10 loose.

Pony Pack: Royal Castle Friends

 The Pony Pack Royal Castle Friends set comes with Spike, Princess Celestia, and Twilight Sparkle.

Release Date: 2011
Value: Since it's still available in most stores, it's only worth about $15-20 for a NIB set. Loose, I would say maybe $3 per pony and $5 for the Princess and Spike.

Pinkie Pie Lunchbox

Release Date: 2010-2011?
Value: Store price was around $10 and I believe that it's no longer available. These pop up on eBay sometimes for around $5 used and $10-15 new.

My Little Pony Princess Celestia

This is one of my favorites, even though she's the wrong color. I can't stop playing with it when I see it in the store, which is why some poor kid in Dayton is going to wind up with a Princess Celestia who doesn't work LOL.

Release Date: 2010-2011
Value: Since it's still available in most stores, it's only worth about $20-25 MIB. She's going for $10 or less loose.

Ponyville Easter Eggs

Capitalizing on the holidays is nothing new! While most people bought this for kids, some lucky collectors held onto the set. Each Easter egg has a tiny pony tucked inside. It came with Sweetie Belle, Rainbow Dash, Cheerilee, Scootaloo, Star Song,  and Pinkie Pie.

Release Date: 2007
Value: The set is worth about $20 as-is NIB, though I see higher prices on it a lot. The ponies are worth $3-5, on the higher side with the egg.

Ponyville Easter Egg Scootaloo

This was part of the Easter egg set and I believe that it was exclusive to that set.

Release Date: 2007/2008
Value: $3 as-is, more like $5 with the egg.

Ponyville Easter Egg Cheerilee

This was part of the Easter egg set and I believe that it was exclusive to that set.

Release Date: 2007/2008
Value: $3 as-is, more like $5 with the egg.

My Little Pony Applejack's Sweet Apple Barn Playset

Applejack's Sweet Apple Barn Playset comes with everything that you need to to recreate your favorite FiM scenes, including animals. I added a photo of it NIB so you can see what it looks like.

Release Date: 2010-2011/Wave 2
Value: I just saw this set at Target, so I know that some stores still have it. It has a MSRP of $14.99, and it can go for $10 loose.

Ponyville Easter Egg Pinkie Pie

This was part of the Easter egg set and I believe that it was exclusive to that set.

Release Date: 2007/2008
Value: $3 as-is, more like $5 with the egg.

My Little Pony Toddler Bedding Set

 This is a set that will make any Pony fan wish she had a smaller bed! The My Little Pony bedding set comes with a flat sheet, fitted sheet, comforter, and pillowcase.

Release Date: 2010s
Value: Most stores sell the set for $30-40 brand new. Loose, you're looking at $10-20 or around $3-5 for each piece.

Twilight Sparkle's Twinkling Balloon

Release Date: 2010

Value: Believe it or not, the MSRP on this is $29.99! It typically sells in stores for around $20-55. A loose set might bring $10-15, but it depends on if you have the accessories and figures.

My Little Pony Jibbitz Crocs Hole Bracelet Shoe Charm

I'm going to put this in the fakie section for now. It looks like a hybrid of Rainbow Dash with a G1 pony.

Release Date: ?

Value: $5-7 new and much less used.

My Little Pony Fluttershy Yay Shirt

As a Fluttershy fan, I love this shirt!

Release Date: 2012

Value: Hot Topic has a ton of MLP shirts for sale right now for around $20-25. You might find them used for $10-15.